Skip to main content

Mastering Behavioral Interviews for Engineering Leaders

As leaders, we’ve all faced the challenge of hiring technically brilliant candidates who ultimately aren't a great fit for our teams. They might be coding wizards, but lack the communication skills, collaborative spirit, or problem-solving approach needed to thrive. This article will provide you with the tools and techniques to move beyond the resume and identify candidates who not only can code, but who will thrive within your team – and help you build something truly exceptional.

The Problem with Traditional Interviews​

Traditional technical interviews often focus heavily on skills and experience. While assessing technical proficiency is important, it's often insufficient to predict long-term success. A candidate can memorize algorithms and data structures, but that doesn't guarantee they’ll be an effective teammate, a proactive problem solver, or a positive influence on the team culture.

Decoding Behavior: Why Behavioral Interviews Matter​

Behavioral interviews delve into how a candidate has handled situations in the past, based on the premise that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior. They allow you to assess crucial “soft skills” like communication, collaboration, conflict resolution, and adaptability – qualities that are often difficult to gauge through technical questions alone. As leaders, we’ve found that while technical skills are essential, a candidate's collaborative spirit and approach to problem-solving are often the key differentiators.

The STAR Method: A Framework for Effective Behavioral Interviewing​

The STAR method is a structured technique for eliciting meaningful responses during behavioral interviews. It encourages candidates to provide detailed, specific examples of their past experiences. Here’s how it works:

  • Situation: Describe the context or situation.
  • Task: Explain the task or challenge you faced.
  • Action: Detail the specific actions you took to address the situation. (This is the most important part – focus on their contribution, not the team’s.)
  • Result: Explain the outcome of your actions and what you learned.

By using the STAR method, you can ensure that candidates provide concrete examples rather than vague generalizations.

Crafting Effective Situational Questions​

Here are some example situational questions you can use to assess key behavioral traits:

  • "Tell me about a time you had to work with a difficult teammate. How did you handle the situation?"
  • "Describe a situation where you faced a significant technical challenge. What steps did you take to overcome it?"
  • "Give me an example of a time you had to explain a complex technical concept to a non-technical audience."
  • "Tell me about a time you made a mistake at work. How did you handle it, and what did you learn?"
  • "Describe a time you had to prioritize multiple tasks with conflicting deadlines. How did you approach the situation?"

Remember to tailor these questions to your specific team's needs and challenges. Don’t be afraid to ask follow-up questions to probe deeper and get more detailed information.

What to Look for Before You Ask​

Before diving into questions, consider the key behaviors your ideal candidate should exhibit. Are you looking for someone who is proactive, collaborative, detail-oriented, or adaptable? Having a clear understanding of these traits will help you focus your questions and interpret the responses more effectively.

Beyond the Answers: Decoding Nonverbal Cues and Assessing Authenticity​

Pay attention not just to what candidates say, but how they say it. Are they enthusiastic and engaged? Do they take ownership of their actions? Do their responses seem genuine and authentic? Be mindful of nonverbal cues like body language, tone of voice, and eye contact. While these cues aren’t foolproof, they can provide valuable insights into a candidate’s personality and character.

Probing for Deeper Understanding​

It's rarely enough to simply accept the initial response. Effective probing is crucial for uncovering the full story and assessing the candidate’s true capabilities. Here are some follow-up questions you can use:

  • “What was the biggest challenge you faced in that situation?”
  • “What specifically did you do to contribute to the solution?”
  • “What would you do differently next time?”
  • “What was the impact of your actions on the team or the project?”
  • “Can you give me a specific example of how you applied that skill?”

Document and Follow Up: Ensuring an Objective Evaluation​

Detailed notes are crucial for objectively comparing candidates and making informed hiring decisions. It’s easy to be swayed by a candidate’s charisma, but detailed notes help you objectively compare candidates based on demonstrated behaviors, rather than relying solely on impressions. Record specific examples of their responses, along with your observations about their demeanor and communication style. After the interview, take time to review your notes and discuss your impressions with other interviewers.

By embracing these techniques, you can move beyond the traditional resume and build a team of talented, collaborative, and motivated individuals who will drive your organization forward.