Skip to main content

Navigating Compensation & Equity Discussions with Your Team

This article provides practical advice for engineering managers on how to navigate sensitive compensation and equity discussions with their teams. It covers important ground and aims to equip you with the tools to foster a motivated, engaged, and high-performing team.

The Foundation: Transparency & Understanding​

Compensation isn’t just about the numbers; it's about recognizing value, motivating performance, and building trust. These conversations are crucial for employee retention, team morale, and overall company success. By being transparent and empathetic, you can create a culture where engineers feel valued and invested in the long-term. This article will guide you through how to effectively communicate about compensation, covering everything from foundational explanations to navigating difficult conversations.

The Components of Total Compensation​

Before diving into individual discussions, ensure you have a solid grasp of your company’s total compensation philosophy. Engineers need to understand all aspects of their remuneration. Here's a breakdown of the core components:

  • Base Salary: The fixed amount paid regularly for the work performed.
  • Bonus: Variable pay tied to individual, team, or company performance. Be prepared to explain how bonuses are calculated – is it based on individual goals, team achievements, overall company profitability, or a combination?
  • Equity: Ownership in the company, often in the form of stock options or restricted stock units (RSUs). This aligns employee interests with the long-term success of the company.
  • Benefits: Non-cash compensation, such as health insurance, paid time off, and retirement plans.

Communicating About Each Component​

Base Salary: When discussing salary adjustments, be clear about the rationale behind the decision. Tie it back to performance, market value, and the engineer’s contributions to the team.

Bonus: Explain the bonus structure clearly, detailing how it's calculated and what goals need to be achieved to earn a bonus.

Equity: Equity can be complex. Explain the type of equity offered (stock options vs. RSUs), the vesting schedule, and the potential value of the equity. Also, be upfront about the risks associated with equity (e.g., company performance, dilution). Cautionary Note: Remember to briefly mention the potential tax implications of exercising stock options or selling RSUs.

Expanding on Market Benchmarking​

It’s crucial to be able to credibly communicate market data when discussing compensation. Leverage internal resources such as compensation bands and salary surveys. Be prepared to explain how the company’s compensation practices align with the market. What if the company isn’t competitive? Be honest. Acknowledge the situation and explain what steps the company is taking to address it. Transparency is key, even if the news isn’t ideal. Focus on non-salary benefits and opportunities for growth if compensation is currently limited.

Equity – Specific Scenarios​

Beyond the basics, be prepared for specific equity-related questions. What happens if an employee is leaving shortly after vesting begins? Explain the unvested portion of the equity and the process for forfeiture. What if the company is acquired? Explain how the acquisition will impact the equity and the potential payout timeline. Having clear answers to these common scenarios will build trust and demonstrate your preparedness.

Handling Difficult Conversations​

Compensation conversations aren’t always easy. Be prepared to address concerns about fairness, market value, or performance evaluations. Here's how to navigate these challenges:

  • Listen Actively: Let the engineer express their concerns without interruption.

  • Empathize: Acknowledge their feelings and show that you understand their perspective.

  • Be Transparent: Explain the rationale behind compensation decisions clearly and honestly.

  • Focus on Performance: Tie compensation back to performance and contributions.

  • Be Open to Feedback: Listen to their suggestions and consider them carefully.

  • Document Everything: Keep a record of the conversation and any commitments you’ve made.

  • Follow up on any commitments you’ve made.

Linking to Performance Reviews​

These compensation discussions should be directly tied to the regular performance review cycle. This reinforces the idea that compensation is earned through performance and contributions. Use the performance review as a platform to discuss career goals, areas for improvement, and how these align with compensation opportunities.

The Long Game: Building Trust & Agency​

Compensation isn’t a one-time event; it’s an ongoing conversation. As a leader, your goal should be to build trust and empower your team. Here's how:

  • Be Proactive: Schedule regular check-ins to discuss compensation and career goals.
  • Provide Feedback: Offer ongoing feedback on performance and areas for growth.
  • Invest in Development: Provide opportunities for engineers to develop their skills and advance their careers.

Building agency means empowering engineers to take ownership of their careers. Give them opportunities to contribute to the company’s success and reward them accordingly. This fosters a culture of accountability, innovation, and high performance.

Connecting Compensation to Ownership​

Ultimately, great compensation conversations aren't just about the numbers; they are about building a team that feels valued, motivated, and invested in the long-term success of the company. By prioritizing transparency, linking compensation to performance, and fostering a culture of growth, you can create a team that thrives.